vrijdag 27 april 2012

Notes on Tati's Play Time

Yesterday I gave my interpretation of Tati’s 1967 film Play Time. I made a complete fool of myself and I should have prepared myself better instead of watching the snooker at the Crucible (that 147!) but here are the notes that I prepared but didn’t use.    

Notes on Tati’s Play Time

When I was invited to say something on the psychogeographical elements in Jacques Tati’s 1967 film Play Time my first reaction was: Who? Now I have seen the film I can understand why evoking psychogeography in relation to Tati’s film might be a good idea.

The origin and legacy of psychogeography is intimately connected to the restructuring of Paris. You could say that it inspired three generations of dissent; first there was Baudelaire and his portrayal of the flaneur, then came the Surrealists with their search for the unconsciousness of Paris, best captured by Louis Aragon in his book on the Paris Peasant and next came the Situationists who took their analysis of how the rationalization of Paris was not just a rationalization of the street plan but of society and daily life itself to a revolutionary conclusion. The work of Haussmann was long finished when Tati came to make his film and already a new breed of architects were preparing themselves to redesign Paris once more and this time do it right. The radiant City of Le Corbusier is the icon of modernist Paris that never was: 18 gigantic tower blocks for which a considerable part of Paris south of the Seine would have to be razed. Psychogeography in that sense was dead simple neighbourhood activism. It is unlikely that Tati ever read Le Corbusier directly but his proposals were part of the intellectual atmosphere and Tati (re)created a modernist town that feels right.

Tati: ‘In the first half of Playtime, I direct the people to follow the architect’s guidelines. Everybody is filmed as if moving in straight lines and feeling prisoners of their surroundings. Modern architecture would like typists to sit straight, would like everyone to take themselves very seriously. In the first part of the film, the architecture plays a leading role but gradually, warmth, contact and friendship as well as the individual I defend, take over this international setting and then neon advertisements make their entrance and the world starts to swirl and it all ends up in a merry-go-round. There are no more straight angles at the end of the film’. (quoted from http://www.blueprintmagazine.co.uk/index.php/architecture/jacques-tati-and-architecture/)

When Tati got to design the city that is the back drop of Play Time he took his ideas of architecture as a monstrous inhuman art and what you get is a city that is has become one gigantic undifferentiated hallway in which the hospital, the workplace, the hotel, the airport are indistinguishable from another. Tati presents the life lived in such a city where nature has been conquered, design reigns supreme as a bad dream and where people have been stripped of their wildness, their senses, forced to ambulate from one place to the next searching for the cheap fix of inane novelties. In the city of Tati wandering is either made impossible (the tourist follow a carefully planned path) or a bureaucratic trick to keep you from reaching your goal, ala Kafka. Halfway the film Tati’s starts to introduce elements of resistance and the people are set free. Just as the docile domestic cow sometimes has something of the primeval wild bovine inside it. 
Strangely in his equation of fully planned, rational environment with the devaluation of humans to drones he almost verbatim follows Le Corbusier and his dream that a well planned city would create well behaved human beings. The psychogeographic drift (Ian Sinclair included) swallows that formula by assuming that drifting, the break-up of a functional activity into a semi-random play is revolutionarily. The city as a watch that runs as smoothly as design allows. Tati buys the ideology of control-through-design but mocks the ideologue. I would argue that this position both overestimates architecture and underestimates people. Strangely enough this idea is still with us but in the opposite way. The idea of the mallable society may have vanished but the precedence of public space over behaviour resurfaces in the broken window theory that gave the impetus for the Zero Tolerance policing that you sometimes hear about here too. So: we no longer believe that design can make us, but an absence of it can break us.
There is a scene in the film where we suddenly stumble on a great open space filled with a ordered series of free standing cubicles. In each cubicle sits one person. It is hard to gauge how the film must have appeared to the viewers in 67 but this is clearly a comic moment: haha look at what those architect fools have thought off, this will never pass in real life. No labourers will ever allow themselves to work caged in a box without any contact with a fellow human. Working like rats in perfect isolation. Of course the cubicles are here but they are not very popular with employers because who knows what your employees are doing down there, hidden away from view…. Probably they are working on their blog.


1 opmerking:

  1. Cháo trai có tác dụng gì?Thịt trai được chế biến thành nhiều món ăn ngon, lạ miệng hấp dẫn, đặc biệt món cháo trai không chỉ món ăn lạ miệng mà còn món ăn bổ dưỡng, chữa bệnh tuyệt vời
    Rau tía tô có tác dụng trị bệnh gì?Để giúp mọi người hiểu rõ hơn tác dụng của loại rau thơm này, sau đây chúng tôi xin chia sẻ một số thông tin ở bài viết dưới đây. Mời bạn cùng xem nhé!
    Tác dụng của rau tía tô với bà bầuĐặc biệt, đối với bà bầu , rau tía tô có những tác dụng đến bất ngờ mà ít ai biết đến.
    Quả bồ kết có tác dụng gì?Đến khi nước nguội thì lấy tay đẩy trĩ cho thụt vào và băng lại để giữ.
    Điều trị viêm phế quản cấp ở trẻ emViêm phế quản là bệnh thường gặp ở trẻ em, bất kể thời tiết thế nào. Và nếu không được chữa trị kịp thời và đúng cách, căn bệnh này rất dễ trở thành mạn tính.
    Điều trị viêm phế quản mãn tính ở trẻ sơ sinhTrẻ sơ sinh rất dễ bị mắc các bệnh đường hô hấp do sức đề kháng còn non yếu. Một trong số các bệnh dễ gặp khi thời tiết thay đổi đó là viêm phế quản.
    Viêm phế quản co thắt ở người lớn có lây không?Tập thể dục đều đặn không chọn các môn thể thao quá sức, làm việc và nghỉ ngơi hợp lý tránh tình trạng stress kéo dài.
    Cách làm món cá thu sốt cà chuaCá thu là loại thực phẩm có giá trị dinh dưỡng cao, dễ dàng có thể chế biến thành món ăn nhiều hấp dẫn như nướng cá thu, kho riềng, sốt cà chua, kho Tô, kho tiêu, làm chả, làm rước, nấu bún
    Cách làm món cá thu nhật kho tiêuCá thu với đặc điểm nhiều thịt và rất ít xương rất thích hợp cho cả người lớn lẫn trẻ em thưởng thức.
    Bệnh đái tháo đường thai kỳ nên kiêng ăn gì?Tỷ lệ mắc đái tháo đường trong thai kỳ là khoảng 5% trên tổng số các bà mẹ mang thai, hay khoảng 200,000 trường hợp mỗi năm tại Hoa kỳ.
    Cách chữa trị hôi miệng hiệu quả nhanh nhấtHôi miệng không phải là vấn đề răng miệng hiếm gặp, nó thể hiện một phần tình trạng bệnh lý cơ thể và khiến cho người bệnh thấy khá tự ti khi giao tiếp.